点击排行
 
正文
全文下载次数:89
2018年第2期   DOI:10.22217/upi.2015.477
中西方城市网络研究差异及思考
Difference Between Chinese and Western Studies on Urban Networks and Its Reflection

李迎成

Li Yingcheng

关键词:城市网络;空间尺度;研究方法;研究重点

Keywords:Urban Networks; Spatial Scales; Research Methods; Research Focus

摘要:

本文从研究尺度、研究方法和研究内容三个方面分析了中西方城市网络研究的差异,并在此基础上对今后城市网络研究进行了初步思考。通过对中西方城市网络研究发展脉络的梳理, 发现西方研究主要关注全球和区域尺度的城市网络,而国内研究则主要关注国家和区域尺度的城市网络。在借鉴世界城市网络理论和方法的基础上,国内研究在城市联系类型选择和网络分析方法方面进行了一些新的探索,但在区域城市网络的分析方法和研究内容方面仍需要对西方多中心城市区域研究的最新进展加以借鉴。在延续现有研究传统的基础上,今后城市网络研究可以更加关注不同空间尺度城市网络的嵌套衔接、城市网络形成和演化机制的实证分析以及城市网络的外部经济分析等。


Abstract:

From the perspectives of research scales, methods and focus, this paper analyzes the difference between Chinese and western studies on urban networks and proposes some future research agendas. By teasing out the developments of both Chinese and western studies on urban networks, this paper finds that whereas western studies focus more on world city networks and polycentric urban regions, Chinese studies attach greater attention to national and regional urban networks. Inspired by the progress in studies on world city networks, Chinese studies have also explored some new types of intercity linkages and ways of analyzing urban networks. However, there is still room for Chinese studies on regional urban networks to learn from recent developments of western studies on polycentric urban regions in terms of research methods and focus. Future studies could emphasize the analysis of urban networks from different spatial scales, the mechanism behind network formation and evolution and the external economies of urban networks.


版权信息:
基金项目:
作者简介:

李迎成,博士,麻省理工学院城市研究与规划系博士后研究员。lych@mit.edu


译者简介:

参考文献:
  • [1] 马学广, 李贵才. 全球流动空间中的当代世界城市网络理论研究[J].

    经济地理, 2011(10): 1630-1637.

    [2] HALL P. The world cities[M]. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1966.

    [3] FRIEDMANN J. The world city hypothesis[J]. Development and Change,

    1986, 17(1): 69-83.

    [4] SASSEN S. The global city: New York, London, Tokyo[M]. Princeton:

    Princeton University Press, 1991.

    [5] TAYLOR P, CATALANO G, WALKER D R F. Measurement of the world

    city network[J]. Urban Studies, 2002, 39(13): 2367-2376.

    [6] TAYLOR P, CATALANO G, GANE N. A geography of global change:

    cities and services, 2000-2001[J]. Urban Geography, 2003, 24(5): 431-41.

    [7] DERUDDER B, TAYLOR P, et al. Hierarchical tendencies and regional

    patterns in the world city network: a global urban analysis of 234 cities[J].

    Regional Studies, 2003, 37(9): 875-886.

    [8] TAYLOR P. Leading world cities: empirical evaluations of urban nodes in

    multiple networks[J]. Urban Studies, 2005, 42(9):1593-1608.

    [9] ROSSI E, TAYLOR P. “Gateway cities” in economic globalization: how

    banks are using Brazilian cities[J]. Tijdschrift voor Economische en

    Sociale Geografie, 2006, 97(5): 515-534.

    [10] TAYLOR P, ARANYA R. A global “urban roller coaster”? connectivity

    changes in the world city network, 2000-2004[J]. Regional Studies, 2008,

    42(1): 1-6.

    [11] DERUDDER B, TAYLOR P, NI P, et al. Pathways of change: shifting

    connectivities in the world city network, 2000-08[J]. Urban Studies, 2010,

    47(9): 1861-1877.

    [12] TAYLOR P, NI P, DERUDDER B, et al. Global urban analysis: a survey of

    cities in globalization[M]. Routledge, 2012.

    [13] TAYLOR P, DERUDDER B, et al. Advanced producer service firms

    as strategic networks, global cities as strategic places[J]. Economic

    Geography, 2014, 90(3): 267-291.

    [14] SANDERSON M, DERUDDER B, et al. Are world cities also world

    immigrant cities? An international, cross-city analysis of global centrality

    and immigration[J]. International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 2015,

    56(3-4): 173-197.

    [15] 宁越敏. 新的国际劳动分工、世界城市和我国中心城市的发展[J]. 城

    市问题, 1991(3): 2-7.

    [16] 甄峰. 信息时代新空间形态研究[J]. 地理科学进展, 2004(3): 16-26.

    [17] 沈丽珍, 顾朝林. 区域流动空间整合与全球城市网络构建[J]. 地理科

    学, 2009(6): 787-793.

    [18] LIU X, DERUDDER B, TAYLOR, P. Mapping the evolution of

    hierarchical and regional tendencies in the world city network, 2000-

    2010[J]. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 2014(43): 51-66.

    [19] MA X, TIMBERLAKE M. World city typologies and national city system

    deterritorialization: USA, China and Japan[J]. Urban Studies, 2013, 50(2):

    255-275.

    [20] BOURNE L, SIMMONS J. Systems of cities: readings on structure growth

    and policy[M]. New York: Oxford University Press, 1978.

    [21] TONTS M, TAYLOR M. Corporate location, concentration and

    performance: large company headquarters in the Australian urban

    system[J]. Urban Studies, 2010, 47(12): 2641-2664.

    [22] 周一星, 杨齐. 我国城镇等级体系变动的回顾及其省区地域类型[J].

    地理学报, 1986, 41(2): 97-111.

    [23] 顾朝林. 中国城镇体系:历史·现状·展望[M]. 商务印书馆, 1992.

    [24] 周一星, 胡智勇. 从航空运输看中国城市体系的空间网络结构[J]. 地

    理研究, 2002, 21(3): 276-86.

    [25] 汪明峰, 宁越敏. 城市的网络优势—— 中国互联网骨干网络结构与节

    点可达性分析[J]. 地理研究, 2006, 25(2): 193-203.

    [26] 赵渺希, 刘铮. 基于生产性服务业的中国城市网络研究[J]. 城市规划,

    2012, 5(9): 23-28.

    [27] GOTTMANN J. Megalopolis or the urbanization of the Northeastern

    Seaboard[J]. Economic Geography, 1957(1): 189-200.

    [28] HARRISON J, HOYLER M. Megaregions: globalization is new urban

    form?[M]. Edward Elgar Publishing, 2015.

    [29] CAMAGNI R, SALONE C. Network urban structures in northern Italy:

    elements for a theoretical framework[J]. Urban Studies, 1993, 30(6): 1053-

    1064.

    [30] HALL P, PAIN K. The polycentric metropolis: learning from mega-city

    regions in Europe[M]. Routledge, 2006.

    [31] MEIJERS E. Polycentric urban regions and the quest for synergy: is a

    network of cities more than the sum of the parts?[J]. Urban Studies, 2005,

    42(4): 765-781.

    [32] MEIJERS E. Measuring polycentricity and its promises[J]. European

    Planning Studies, 2008, 16(9): 1313-1323.

    [33] BURGER M, MEIJERS E. Form follows function? linking morphological

    and functional polycentricity[J]. Urban Studies, 2012, 49(5): 1127-1149.

    [34] BURGER M, MEIJERS E, VAN OORT F. Multiple perspectives on

    functional coherence: heterogeneity and multiplexity in the Randstad[J].

    Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, 2014, 105(4): 444-

    464.

    [35] BURGER M, VAN DER KNAAP B, WALL R. Polycentricity and the

    multiplexity of urban networks[J]. European Planning Studies, 2014, 22(4):

    816-840.

    [36] MEIJERS E, BURGER M, HOOGERBRUGGE M. Borrowing size

    in networks of cities: city size, network connectivity and metropolitan

    functions in Europe[J]. Papers in Regional Science, 2015, 95(1).

    [37] 朱查松, 王德, 罗震东. 中心性与控制力:长三角城市网络结构的组织

    特征及演化——企业联系的视角[J]. 城市规划学刊, 2014(4): 24-30.

    [38] 李仙德. 基于上市公司网络的长三角城市网络空间结构研究[J]. 地理

    科学进展, 2014, 33(12): 1587-1600.

    [39] 唐子来, 李涛. 长三角地区和长江中游地区的城市体系比较研究:基

    于企业关联网络的分析方法[J]. 城市规划学刊, 2014(2): 24-31.

    [40] 赵渺希, 钟烨, 徐高峰. 中国三大城市群多中心网络的时空演化[J]. 经

    济地理, 2015, 35(3): 52-59.

    [41] ALDERSON A, BECKFIELD J. Power and position in the world city

    system[J]. American Journal of Sociology, 2004, 109(4): 811-851.

    [42] ALDERSON A, BECKFIELD J, SPRAGUE-JONES J. Intercity relations

    and globalization: the evolution of the global urban hierarchy, 1981-

    2007[J]. Urban Studies, 2010, 47(9): 1899-1923.

    [43] SMITH D, TIMBERLAKE M. World city networks and hierarchies,

    1977-1997: an empirical analysis of global air travel links[J]. American

    Behavioral Scientist, 2001, 44(10): 1656-1678.

    [44] MAHUTGA M, MA X, SMITH D, et al. Economic globalization and the

    structure of the world city system: the case of airline passenger data[J].

    Urban Studies, 2010, 47(9): 1925-1947.

    [45] CHOI J, BARNETT G, CHON B. Comparing world city networks:

    a network analysis of internet backbone and air transport intercity

    linkages[J]. Global Networks, 2006, 6(1): 81-99.

    [46] 罗震东, 何鹤鸣, 耿磊. 基于客运交通流的长江三角洲功能多中心结

    构研究[J]. 城市规划学刊, 2011(2): 16-23.

    [47] LIU X, DERUDDER B, WU K. Measuring polycentric urban development

    in China: an intercity transportation network perspective[J]. Regional

    Studies, 2016, 50(8): 1302-1315.

    [48] 甄峰, 王波, 陈映雪. 基于网络社会空间的中国城市网络特征—— 以

    新浪微博为例[J]. 地理学报, 2012, 67(8): 1031-1043.

    [49] 韦江绿, 罗震东. 基于高端时尚消费品销售空间的中国城市控制力结

    构研究[J]. 地理科学, 2012(2): 162-168

    [50] 程玉鸿, 孟俊华. 基于高端消费文化视角的中国城市中心性及其网络

    结构的实证分析[J]. 经济地理, 2014(2): 28-34, 49.

    [51] MATTHIESSEN C, SCHWARZ A. World cities of scientific knowledge:

    systems, networks and potential dynamics: an analysis based on

    bibliometric indicators[J]. Urban Studies, 2010, 47(9): 1879-1897.

    [52] 吕拉昌, 李勇. 基于城市创新职能的中国创新城市空间体系[J]. 地理

    学报, 2010(2): 177-190.

    [53] MA H, FANG C, PANG B, et al. The effect of geographical proximity on

    scientific cooperation among Chinese cities from 1990 to 2010[J]. PLoS

    One, 2014, 9(11): e111705.

    [54] MA H, FANG C, PANG B, et al. Structure of Chinese city network as

    driven by technological knowledge flows[J]. Chinese Geographical

    Science, 2015, 25(4): 498-510.

    [55] 牛欣, 陈向东. 城市间创新联系及创新网络空间结构研究[J]. 管理学

    报, 2013(4): 575-582.

    [56] 吴志强, 陆天赞. 引力和网络:长三角创新城市群落的空间组织特征

    分析[J]. 城市规划学刊, 2015(2): 31-39.

    [57] VAN OORT F, BURGER M, RASPE O. On the economic foundation of

    the urban network paradigm: spatial integration, functional integration and

    economic complementarities within the Dutch Randstad[J]. Urban Studies,

    2010, 47(4): 725-748.

    [58] 顾朝林, 庞海峰. 基于重力模型的中国城市体系空间联系与层域划分[J].

    地理研究, 2008, 27(1): 1-12.

    [59] 冷炳荣, 杨永春, 李英杰, 等. 中国城市经济网络结构空间特征及其复

    杂性分析[J]. 地理学报, 2011(2): 199-211.

    [60] 马学广, 李贵才. 世界城市网络研究方法论[J]. 地理科学进展, 2012,

    31(2): 255-263.

    [61] NEAL Z. Differentiating centrality and power in the world city network[J].

    Urban Studies, 2011, 48(13): 2733-2748.

    [62] LIU X, DERUDDER B. Analyzing urban networks through the lens of

    corporate networks: a critical review[J]. Cities, 2013(31): 430-437.

    [63] HENNEMANN S, DERUDDER B. An alternative approach to the

    calculation and analysis of connectivity in the world city network[J].

    Environment and Planning B, 2014, 41(3): 392-412.

    [64] 赵渺希, 吴康, 刘行健, 等. 城市网络的一种算法及其实证比较[J]. 地

    理学报, 2014(2): 169-183.

    [65] 刘铮, 王世福, 赵渺希, 等. 有向加权型城市网络的探索性分析[J]. 地

    理研究, 2013, 32(7): 1253-1268.

    [66] CARROLL W. Global cities in the global corporate network[J].

    Environment and Planning A, 2007, 39(10): 2297-2323.

    [67] GREEN N. Functional Polycentricity: a formal definition in terms of social

    network analysis[J]. Urban Studies, 2007, 44(11): 2077-2103.

    [68] 李丹丹, 汪涛, 魏也华, 等. 中国城市尺度科学知识网络与技术知识网

    络结构的时空复杂性[J]. 地理研究, 2015, 34(3): 525-540.

    [69] DE GOEI B, BURGER M, VAN OORT F, et al. Functional polycentrism

    and urban network development in the Greater South East, United

    Kingdom: Evidence from Commuting Patterns, 1981-2001[J]. Regional

    Studies, 2010, 44(9): 1149-1170.

    [70] TAYLOR P, DERUDDER B, et al. City-dyad analyses of China’s

    integration into the world city network[J]. Urban Studies, 2014, 51(5): 868-

    882.

    [71] NEAL Z. From central places to network bases: a transition in the US

    urban hierarchy, 1900-2000[J]. City & Community, 2011, 10(1): 49-75.

    [72] NIJMAN J. Breaking the rules: Miami in the urban hierarchy[J]. Urban

    Geography, 1996, 17(1): 5-22.

    [73] TIMBERLAKE M, SANDERSON M, MA X, et al. Testing a global city

    hypothesis: an assessment of polarization across US cities[J]. City &

    Community, 2012, 11(1): 74-93.

    [74] BURGER M, MEIJERS E, VAN OORT F. Regional spatial structure and

    retail amenities in the Netherlands[J]. Regional Studies, 2014, 48(12):

    1972-1992.

    [75] CIRILLI A, VENERI P. Spatial structure and Carbon Dioxide (CO2)

    emissions due to commuting: an analysis of Italian urban areas[J]. Regional

    Studies, 2014, 48(12): 1993-2005.

    [76] BATHELT H, MALMBERG A, MASKELL P. Clusters and knowledge:

    local buzz, global pipelines and the process of knowledge creation[J].

    Progress in Human Geography, 2004, 28(1): 31-56.

    [77] CASTELLS M. The information age: economy, society and culture. Vol. 1,

    The Rise of the Network Society[M]. Oxford: Blackwell, 2000.

    [78] 冷炳荣, 杨永春, 谭一洺, 等. 结构动力机制视角下的城市网络解释框

    架[J]. 地理研究, 2013, 32(7): 1243-1252.

    [79] PHELPS N, OZAWA T. Contrasts in agglomeration: proto-industrial,

    industrial and post-industrial forms compared[J]. Progress in Human

    Geography, 2003, 27(5): 583-604.


《国际城市规划》编辑部    北京市车公庄西路10号东楼E305/320    100037
邮箱:upi@vip.163.com  电话:010-58323806  传真:010-58323825
京ICP备13011701号-6  京公网安备11010802014223

2793257