比什·桑亚尔

Bish Sanyal

关键词：非正规住房 ；房地产市场 ；政策 ；发展中国家 ；贫民窟

Keywords：Informal Housing; Real Estate Market; Policy; Developing Countries; Slum

摘要：

本文通过评述学者和实践者基于来自巴西、印度和中国的实证经验，对城市非正规住房市场的关键性问题进行探讨。首先介绍了世界银行进行项目研究时政策制定者对非正规住房的观点，其次对就地升级、提供私有产权和贫民窟再开发三种主要政策干预的效果进行分析，最后提出为达到更好的非正规住房市场干预效果有待解决的问题。

Abstract：

This study draws critical issues on urban informal real estate markets through lessons learned by academics and practitioners based on empirical evidence from Brazil, India, and China. The first part provides a brief synopsis of how policy makers viewed informal settlements at the time of the World Bank’s study. The second part is a brief analysis of three key policy interventions designed to improve the functioning of informal real estate markets, i.e., in-situ upgrading, offering private property rights, and slum redevelopment. The third part concludes by proposing three research questions that need to be addressed to better intervene in informal real estate markets.

比什·桑亚尔，麻省理工学院城市研究与规划系教授，SPURS/Humphrey 项目主任

陈宇琳，清华大学建筑学院城市规划系副教授，麻省理工学院 SPURS 学者。chenyulin@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn

• [1] ACOLIN A, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M. Urban governance and development of informality in China and India[M] // BIRCH E L, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M, eds. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016: 4-23.
  [2] ADAMS D W, FITCHETT D A. Informal finance in low-income countries[M]. Colorado: Westview Press, 1992.
  [3] ADHVARYU B. The Ahmedabad urban development plan-making process: a critical review[J]. Planning Practice and Research, 2011, 26(2): 229-250.
  [4] AHLUWALIA I J. Transforming Indian cities: challenges and opportunities[M]. New Delhi: Harper Collins Publishers India, 2014.
  [5] ANGEL SH, MAYO S K. The housing indicators program: a report on progress and plans for the future[J]. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 1993, 8(1): 13-47.
  [6] ANGEL SH. Housing policy matters: a global analysis[M]. New York: Oxford University Press, 2000.
  [7] AYRES R L. Banking on the poor: the World Bank and world poverty[M]. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 1984.
  [8] BALAKRISHNAN S. Periurban land markets in the Bangalore region[M] // BIRCH E L, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M, eds. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016: 107-119.
  [9] BALLANEY S, PATEL B. 2009. Using the “development plan-town planning scheme” mechanism to appropriate land and build urban infrastructure[M] // India infrastructure report 2009. New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2009: 190-204.
  [10] BANERJEE A V, DUFLO E. Poor economics: a radical rethinking of the way to fight global poverty[M]. New York: Public Affairs, 2011.
  [11] BECKER G S. A theory of the allocation of time[J]. Economic Journal, 1965, 75(299): 493-517.
  [12] BURGESS R. Helping some to help themselves: third world housing policies and development strategies[M] // KOSTA M, ed. Beyond self-help housing. Munich: Profil Verlag, 1992: 75-91.
  [13] BURNS L S, GREBLER L. The housing of nations: analysis and policy in a comparative framework[M]. New York: Halsted, 1977.
  [14] CAMERER C F, LOEWENSTEIN G, RABIN M, eds. Advances in behavioral economics[M]. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2004.
  [15] CHATTARAJ S. Property markets without property rights: Dharavi’s informal real estate market[M] // BIRCH E L, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M, eds. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016: 94-106.
  [16] CHEEMA G S. Urban shelter and services: public policies and management approaches[M]. New York: Praeger, 1987.
  [17] COHEN M, MADAVO C, DUNKERLEY H. Learning by doing: world bank lending for urban development 1972-1982[R]. Washington, DC: World Bank, 1983.
  [18] DE SOTO H. The mystery of capital: why capitalism triumphs in the west and fails everywhere else[M]. New York: Basic Books, 2000.
  [19] FRANK A G. Latin America: underdevelopment or revolution. essays on the development of underdevelopment and the immediate enemy[M]. New York: Modern Reader/Monthly Review Press, 1969.
  [20] GALIANI S, SCHARGRODSKY E. Urban land titling: lessons from a natural experiment[M] // BIRCH E L, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M, eds. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016: 47-54.
  [21] GOUVERNEUR D. Making a difference in the predominantly informal city[M] // BIRCH E L, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M, eds. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016: 155-175.
  [22] GULYANI S, CONNORS G. Urban upgrading in Africa: a summary of rapid assessments in ten countries[EB/OL]. World Bank’s Africa Infrastructure Department. (2002)[2014-07-20]. http://web.mit.edu/urbanupgrading/upgrading/case–examples/overview-africa/country-assessments/download/10-CountrySummary.pdf.
  [23] HIRSCHMAN A O. Bias for hope: essays on development and Latin America[M]. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1971.
  [24] HIRSCHMAN A O. Getting ahead collectively: grassroots experiences in Latin America[M]. New York: Pergamon Press, 1984.
  [25] JUMANI U. Dealing with poverty: self-employment for poor rural women[M]. New Delhi: Sage Publications, 1991.
  [26] KEARE D H, JIMENEZ E. Progressive development and affordability in the design of urban shelter projects[R]. World Bank Staff Working Papers, Number 560. Washington, DC: World Bank, 1983.
  [27] KUNDU A. Housing no hope for the poor[J]. Economic and Political Weekly, 1990, 25(31): 1709-1711.
  [28] LU J H, ROWE P, ZHANG J. Modern urban housing in China: 1840-2000[M]. Munich: Prestel, 2001.
  [29] McKinsey Global Institute. India’s urban awakening: building inclusive cities sustaining economic growth[R]. Mumbai and New York: McKinsey and Company, 2010.
  [30] MEINZEN-DICK R, MWANGI E. Cutting the web of interests: pitfalls of formalizing property rights[J]. Land Use Policy, 2009, 26(1): 36-43.
  [31] MHUPA: Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation, Government of India. Guidelines for slum-free city planning, Rajiv Awas Yojana (RAY)[EB/OL]. (2011)[2014-07-20]. http://mhupa.gov.in/wnew/RAY%20Guidelines-%20English.pdf.
  [32] MORSS E R. Institutional destruction resulting from Donor and project proliferation in Sub-Saharan African countries[J]. World Development, 1984, 12(4): 465-470.
  [33] MOSER C. Gender planning in the Third World: meeting practical and strategic gender needs[J]. World Development, 1989, 17(11): 1799-1825.
  [34] MUKHIJA V. Squatters as developers? slum redevelopment in Mumbai[M]. Hampshire: Ashgate Publishing Limited, 2003.
  [35] MUKHIJA V. Rehousing Mumbai: formalizing slum land markets through redevelopment[M] // BIRCH E L, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M, eds. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016: 125-139.
  [36] OSTROM E. Collective action and the evolution of social norms[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 2000, 14(3): 137-158.
  [37] PAYNE G, ed. Law land, rights and innovation: improving tenure security for the urban poor[M]. London: ITDG, 2002.
  [38] PERLMAN J E. The formalization of informal real estate transactions in Rio’s Favelas[M] // BIRCH E L, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M, eds. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016: 58-82.
  [39] POLLAK R A. Gary Becker’s contributions to family and household economics[J]. Review of Economics of the Household, 2003, 1(1/2): 111-141.
  [40] RICHARDSON H W. Whither national urban policy in developing countries?[J]. Urban Studies, 1987, 24: 227-244.
  [41] ROBERTS B R. Organizing strangers[M]. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1973.
  [42] RODGERS G, ed. Urban poverty and the labor market: access to jobs and incomes in Asian and Latin American cities[R]. Geneva: International Labor Office, 1989.
  [43] RODWIN L, ed. Shelter, settlement and development[M]. Boston: Allen and Union, 1987.
  [44] ROWEIS S. Urban planning in early and late capitalist societies: outline of a theoretical perspective[M] // DEAR M, SCOTT A J, eds. Urbanization and urban planning in capitalist society. London: Methuen, 1981.
  [45] SANYAL B, DEUSKAR C. A better way to grow? town planning schemes as a hybrid land readjustment process in Ahmedabad, India[M] // INGRAM G K, HONG Y, eds. Value capture and land policies. Boston: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, 2012: 149-182.
  [46] SANYAL B, FAWAZ M. The transformation of an olive grove: an institutional perspective from Beirut, Lebanon[M] // VERMA N, ed. Planning and institutions. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science, 2007: 207-228.
  [47] SANYAL B, MUKHIJA V. Institutional pluralism and housing delivery: a case of unforeseen conflicts in Mumbai, India[J]. World Development, 2001, 29(12): 2043-2057.
  [48] SANYAL B. Learning before doing: a critical analysis of the privatization concept in shelter policies of international institutions[J]. Open House International, 1986, 11(4): 13-21.
  [49] SANYAL B. Problems of cost-recovery in development projects: experience of the Lusaka upgrading and site/service projects[J]. Urban Studies, 1987, 24: 285-295.
  [50] SCHON D A. 1987. Institutional learning in shelter and settlement policies[M] // RODWIN L, ed. Shelter, settlement, and development. Boston: Allen & Unwin. 1987: 360-401.
  [51] SEELIG M Y. The architecture of self-help communities: the first international design competition for the urban environment of developing countries[M]. New York: Architectural Record Books, 1978.
  [52] SILVA P C, MAUTNER Y. Tenure regularization programs in favelas in Brazil[M] // BIRCH E L, CHATTARAJ S, WACHTER S M, eds. Slums: how informal real estate markets work. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2016: 83-93.
  [53] TURNER J F C. Barriers and channels for housing development in modernizing countries[J]. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 1967, 34: 354-363.
  [54] TURNER J F C. Housing in three dimensions: terms of reference for the housing question redefined[M] // BROMLEY R, ed. The urban informal sector: critical perspectives on employment and housing policies. Oxford: Pergamon Press, 1979: 1135-1146.
  [55] UN-Habitat. The legacy of urban management program[J]. Habitat Debate, 2005, 11(4).
  [56] UNHCR. 2010. Update on UNHCR’s global programs and partnerships[EB/OL]. (2010)[2014-07-20]. http:// www.unhcr.org/4ca5deb59.pdf.
  [57] WATSON V. Urban planning and twenty-first century cities: can it meet the challenge?[M] // GARLAND A M, MASSOUMI M, RUBLE B A, eds. Global urban poverty: setting the agenda. Washington, DC: Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, 2007: 205-237.
  [58] WERLIN H. 1999. The slum upgrading myth[J]. Urban Studies, 1999, 36(9): 1523-1534.
  [59] WOODBURY C. The future of cities and urban redevelopment[M]. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1953.
  [60] World Bank. The task ahead for the cities of developing countries[R]. BEIER G, CHURCHILL A, COHEN M, RENAUD B. World Bank Staff Working Paper No. 209. Washington, DC: World Bank, 1975.
  [61] YUNUS M. Banker to the Poor[M]. New York: Public Affairs, 1999.

• 收起